
Energy Secretary Chris Wright (Screen Capture/CSPAN)
The Trump administration is keeping a Michigan coal plant available into winter while it asks an appeals court to revisit a ruling against it.
Energy Secretary Chris Wright ordered the Midcontinent Independent System Operator, which runs the Midwest grid, and Consumers Energy to have the J.H. Campbell plant, in West Olive, Michigan, available to run through Feb. 12, 2027, the Energy Department announced Nov. 14. Emergency orders for seven other power plants in six states end between Nov. 20 and Dec. 31, the department’s records show.
“Ensuring coal plants such as the Campbell Plant are available to operate has prevented blackouts and likely saved lives,” Wright said in the release. “Americans deserve access to affordable, reliable, and secure electricity regardless of whether the wind is blowing or the sun is shining.”
The order directs the grid operator to use economic dispatch, running Campbell only when the emergency requires it and keeping costs down, the department said.
Midwest grid operator media relations adviser McKenzie Barbknecht said in a statement to the Daily Caller News Foundation that plants kept open under the orders “are dispatched like any other resource – through economic dispatch to meet system needs at the lowest cost.”
The grid operator “does not disclose unit specific generation information,” Barbknecht said.
It is the first Campbell order since Sept. 11, when the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit struck down Wright’s original emergency order for the plant. The department has asked the court to rehear the case, and that request is still pending, Utility Dive reported on Nov. 16.
The court threw out only the first Campbell order and has not reviewed the orders that followed it, the American Public Power Association noted in October.
The first of the other orders, for Units 3 and 4 at Constellation Energy’s Eddystone Generating Station in Pennsylvania, was scheduled to end Nov. 20. Orders for plants in Florida, Washington, Indiana and Colorado run out over the following five weeks.
Constellation said in a statement to the DCNF that it “will continue to keep Eddystone Units 3 and 4 operational for as long as the DOE 202 Orders remain in force.”
Since Aug. 23, 2026, both units ran Sept. 1-3, Unit 3 ran again Sept. 4 and Unit 4 ran Oct. 14. Operating the two units cost about $4.9 million in the order’s first term, from May 31 to Aug. 28, 2025, and $5.1 million in its second, the company said. When it sought repayment from PJM Interconnection, which runs the mid-Atlantic grid, Constellation deducted the net revenue the units earned.
The department renewed its order for Unit 4 at Talen Energy’s Wagner Generating Station in Anne Arundel County, Maryland, on Nov. 17, the day the previous order ended, its website shows. The new order runs about six weeks, through Dec. 31, after two 90-day terms.
PJM applied for the order after the unit ran out of its allowed operating hours during a summer heat spell, the department said in a Nov. 18 release.
“The Trump Administration is committed to keeping the lights on and ensuring American families and businesses have access to affordable, reliable, and secure power,” a department spokesperson said in a statement to the DCNF.
“At the request of PJM, the Energy Department took decisive action to strengthen grid reliability and ensure Americans across the mid-Atlantic region have a dependable power grid that delivers electricity when they need it most,” the spokesperson added.
Talen and the Michigan attorney general’s office did not respond to the DCNF’s requests for comment.
Consumers expects to ask the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to let it recover $303 million in costs under the orders through Sept. 30, “including amounts already requested,” after applying $344 million in revenue from the Midwest grid operator, the company said in its quarterly filing.
Consumers spokesman Brian Wheeler said in a statement to the DCNF that the company would not “speculate on future costs.” He said Consumers has asked federal regulators “to allow us to recover most of those costs for the first three 90-day periods from customers in 10 other Midwest states who benefited from that power.”
“Those cases are pending. We will submit additional cost recovery filings for costs incurred complying with all subsequent 90-day periods,” Wheeler said.
The utility wants ratepayers in 11 states, from Michigan and Illinois to Montana and the Dakotas, to cover the plant’s costs, the Environmental Defense Fund said, according to Utility Dive.
Wheeler said the utility “will continue to follow the law and operate our Campbell plant,” Utility Dive reported. “Consistent with these emergency orders, we will work to ensure that everyone who benefits from power from the Campbell plant across the Midwest pays their fair share.”
“Coal-fired power plants have become a political football. Democrats want to shut them down, Republicans want to keep them running indefinitely, and the political pendulum keeps on swinging,” Travis Fisher, director of energy and environmental policy studies at the Cato Institute, said in a statement to the DCNF.
“This is an irrational way to manage the electricity grid, and consumers are left dealing with the consequences. The answer is to get politics out of electricity decisions, rather than forcing ratepayers to pay for Washington’s latest intervention,” Fisher added.
Jordan Nader, a resident senior fellow for energy and environment at the R Street Institute, said in a statement to the DCNF that the new order does not meet the guardrails his colleague Michael Giberson called for in May.
Those guardrails “should be transparent, based on cost-benefit analysis, and demonstrate consideration of alternatives,” Nader said.
The Midwest grid operator should spread Campbell’s costs across its region when it calls on the plant, he said.
“It would be improper to isolate the costs and allocate them only to Michigan,” he added.
The department still says the plant is needed. It cited a report by federal regulators and the North American Electric Reliability Corporation, saying the Arctic cold of winter 2026, including Winter Storm Fern, showed the grid needs plants that can run on demand.
Environmental and consumer groups say there is no emergency, Utility Dive reported.
“Someone will be left holding the financial bag,” Environmental Law & Policy Center CEO Howard Learner said in a statement reported by Utility Dive.
The Sierra Club’s Jessi Eidbo called the order “yet another illegal and expensive extension,” the Associated Press reported on Nov. 16.
“The Trump Administration’s unlawful actions have created a horribly expensive mess with no easy answer for who pays for it,” Karlee Weinmann, research and communications manager at the utility watchdog Energy and Policy Institute, said in a statement to the DCNF.
Democratic Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel said on Nov. 17 she would ask the department to rehear the new order. Her office has filed six such requests and six petitions with the D.C. Circuit, according to a Nov. 17 press release from her office.
“In September, a federal court ruled DOE’s first Campbell plant order was entirely illegal, and this seventh order makes no further effort to comply with the law,” Nessel said.
“My office will continue to pursue every measure and remedy available to us as we seek, for the people of Michigan, relief from these continuing unlawful orders which keep an obsolete coal-plant burning to the detriment of our state residents,” Nessel added.
“Green zealots like to call the power situation a ‘fabricated emergency’ because the power always seems to work just fine at their house. They expect us to forget winter storm Fern when grid operators declared a real emergency because they were in need of power generation,” Larry Behrens, communications director of Power The Future, said in a statement to the DCNF.
“The Campbell plant delivered critical energy when Michigan needed it the most, and no doubt if there were blackouts Dana Nessel would’ve been among the first to blame the Trump Administration. Nessel’s tired response is always the same: shut down a working plant, kill jobs, and hope the weather cooperates,” he added.
Closing Campbell would pull “needed energy off the grid as the coldest time of the year approaches,” Behrens said.
“This winter, families and businesses will need baseload plants like Campbell for lighting and heating,” Ted Ellis, deputy director of energy and environment policy at the America First Policy Institute, said in a statement to the DCNF.
“Secretary Wright is delivering an America First policy solution to a real problem on the ground: reliable power plants, including coal generation, are being retired before dependable replacements exist,” Ellis added.
Consumers had planned to close the 64-year-old plant on May 31, 2025, which the department says was 15 years short of its design life. The Nov. 13 order is the seventh for the plant since May 2025, the AP reported.
The next order to expire after Eddystone covers Unit 1 at the Stanton Energy Center in Orlando, Florida, on Nov. 30.
All content created by the Daily Caller News Foundation, an independent and nonpartisan newswire service, is available without charge to any legitimate news publisher that can provide a large audience. All republished articles must include our logo, our reporter’s byline and their DCNF affiliation. For any questions about our guidelines or partnering with us, please contact [email protected].