
Screen Capture/PBS NewsHour
Elections (and politicians) come and go. Title VII does not.
Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibits employers from discriminating against employees or applicants on the basis of race, color, religion, sex or national origin. While the results of the midterms may tempt some federal contractors to believe they have the green light to carry on with illegal diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) practices, the two-part, $29.5 million resolution just announced by the Justice Department and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) with Lockheed Martin should be a clear warning otherwise.
Lockheed agreed to pay $22 million to the United States to resolve False Claims Act allegations that, from 2019 onward, it certified compliance with federal contractor nondiscrimination rules while using race or sex in employment decisions. The EEOC had alleged that Lockheed had unlawfully discriminated against white employees and applicants on the basis of their race or sex.
On top of that, it will pay approximately $7.5 million to more than 1,000 employees as part of an EEOC agreement to resolve alleged discrimination charges. That EEOC recovery is the largest class of workers to publicly recover under a Title VII settlement tied to alleged DEI practices. While Lockheed admitted no liability, it’s paying a pretty hefty price to settle the allegations.
This is the fourth False Claims Act settlement under the Justice Department’s Civil Rights Fraud Initiative. The Civil Rights Fraud Initiative has now produced four settlements in roughly 18 months totaling more than $85 million. IBM was first. Deloitte and Accenture followed. Lockheed is the largest contractor yet to write the check. Associate Attorney General Stanley E. Woodward Jr. put the principle plainly: companies that do business with the federal government “should not make DEI compensation decisions that prioritize an employee’s race over the merit of their work.” The Department, he added, remains committed to eliminating those practices from workplaces that receive taxpayer funds.
The specific allegations are familiar in outline and concrete in detail. Lockheed operated a “Compensation Adder” program that awarded extra pay increases to the top 20 percent of employees in each business area. Allegedly the company ran statistical analyses to flag outliers based on the race and sex composition of those lists, then pressured leaders to adjust selections, removing non-minority employees and adding minority employees until the flags cleared. According to the Justice Department’s findings, one director wrote:
“we will identify at least 11 additional PoC adds from other functions” to add to the Comp Adder list “and the level 2 Race flag will clear (assuming everything else remains static). Let’s goooooooooo”
For translation purposes, “PoC” is Persons of Color. That is, non-white people.
The government further alleged that non-public race- and sex-based workforce composition goals influenced hiring and promotion decisions, that a Management Incentive Compensation Plan included metrics tied to preferred demographics tracked with color-coded summaries and that certain training, mentoring and leadership programs were limited by race or sex. The EEOC charge focused on race discrimination against employees in performance assessments and compensation decisions under the same Comp Adder program.
Lockheed has said the programs at issue have already ended, which is a positive step in the right direction. But Lockheed and other companies, would be well advised to take steps now to make these changes enduring. The risk is not only from most visible programs; it is the residual machinery—statistical flags, demographic tracking that still shapes decisions, restricted pipelines, or compensation metrics that quietly reappear under new labels. Those practices will eventually be exposed and investigated. Rather than ending a program after the investigation starts, it would be far better for companies to simply consistently apply a merit-based system all along.
Elections change personnel. They do not change Title VII or the Supreme Court’s recent interpretation. A contractor that considers the latest midterm results as permission to keep demographic scorecards, or to treat one group of employees as a residual category until the numbers “look right,” is misreading both the law and the enforcement pattern. The current EEOC leadership has shown it will likewise pursue Title VII claims that arise from the same practices. The combination of government recovery plus direct payments to employees now raises both the cost and the negative visibility.
Taxpayers have a straightforward interest. Lockheed is the largest federal contractor in the country. The people who design, build and support systems that protect American forces should be selected, promoted and compensated on the basis of competence and performance, not on whether their inclusion moves a color-coded target. Treating every employee as a valued individual based on merit is not a partisan preference.
Boards and general counsels still face the same practical choice that existed after IBM, Deloitte and Accenture. Simply removing or renaming a diversity office, scrubbing public language, or issuing a statement about merit does not eliminate exposure if the internal processes continue to sort people by race or sex. The real fix is more complete and more durable: audit compensation, promotion, hiring and development programs against the nondiscrimination certifications already in the contract file; end eligibility rules and statistical adjustments based on race or sex; stop tying pay or leadership evaluation to demographic percentages; document the change so it survives the next review and makes these changes transparent to the shareholders, employees and the federal government.
Four settlements make the cost of waiting crystal clear. Companies maintaining illegal practices in the hopes the next election will change the legal baseline are betting against both the statute, legal precedent and the recent enforcement record. Merit is not a slogan that activates only when a particular party is in office. It is the standard that applies to every employee, every day, under every contract.
And that is a fundamental starting point for businesses to get back to business.
Douglas H. Napier is executive chairman and CEO of 1792 Exchange, a nonprofit organization that helps companies get back to business through data, research and confidential engagement with boards and executives.
The views and opinions expressed in this commentary are those of the author and do not reflect the official position of the Daily Caller News Foundation.
All content created by the Daily Caller News Foundation, an independent and nonpartisan newswire service, is available without charge to any legitimate news publisher that can provide a large audience. All republished articles must include our logo, our reporter’s byline and their DCNF affiliation. For any questions about our guidelines or partnering with us, please contact [email protected].