Commentary: Big Tent Ideas

SpaceX First In Line As Texas Resumes Data Center Permitting

SpaceX First In Line As Texas Resumes Data Center Permitting

(Photo courtesy of SpaceX)

The Texas Commission on Environmental Quality (TCEQ) issued an air permit on Nov. 16 for SpaceX’s planned data center and gas-fired power plant on a 444-acre site near the Port of Brownsville, inside the city of Starbase. Politico reports that the project will include 35 natural gas turbines, 750 megawatts of generation, enough to run a supercomputing campus without draining the grid.

So, a company wants to put more than $24 billion into South Texas, build its own gas-fired generation and keep its load off the grid, which seems like exactly the model Texas Gov. Greg Abbott had touted for the last year or more. The mystery is why this permit had to wait for an election to be over to be issued.

The SpaceX plan was always to build its own behind-the-meter power. That’s the whole ballgame if you’ve spent the last year fretting that data centers will crash the Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT) grid and stick households with the bill. This project does not ask ERCOT for a hookup, and SpaceX specifically says the point is to make sure its energy demands “do not compete with local homes or businesses or shift generation costs onto existing ratepayers.” If you are serious about protecting the grid, this is the model you promote — not the one you freeze.

The company also says the campus is expected to support more than 500 permanent jobs, has already generated more than 3,000 construction jobs, and that it is committing $220 million to expand Brownsville’s water and wastewater systems. So, bring your own power, pay for water system improvements, and don’t dump the costs on the neighbors. 

How did this project get stuck in Abbott’s freezer?

SpaceX filed the air permit registration on Sept. 8. Thirteen days later, Abbott told TCEQ to halt data center permits until ERCOT “completes its review.” His letter said data centers “must pay their own way, protect our grid and water.” Cool, as far as it goes. The SpaceX plan had always been designed to do exactly that.

But the Sept. 21 order was not really about grid hookups. Abbott had already paused data center interconnections in August. The TCEQ freeze was aimed at behind the meter projects — the ones that generate their own power and might otherwise bypass the ERCOT system. In other words, Texas specifically delayed projects that would not burden the grid because the Governor was looking for political cover during a tough reelection race. That isn’t energy policy — it’s a campaign tactic.

Abbott lost overwhelmingly to Democrat Gina Hinojosa on November 3. On Friday, November 13, his office notified TCEQ that ERCOT had finished gathering information on community impacts — just one of several issues he had asked the grid operator to study. On Monday, TCEQ resumed its normal permit review process, issuing the SpaceX permit the same day. 

But ERCOT’s full findings are not due until Dec. 10, and TCEQ is not scheduled to review them until a week later. Nothing about the SpaceX project’s turbines, its acreage, or its off-grid design changed between Sept. 8 and Nov. 16. The only things that changed were the calendar and the person who will be Governor of Texas after the first of the year.

That is the part that ought to concern anyone who wants Texas to keep winning these major investments that spur so much economic opportunity. SpaceX is also planning a roughly $50 billion supercomputing campus in Arizona, demonstrating that capital has options on where it will be deployed. When a state freezes even projects that show up with their own natural gas generation, then unfreezes them the minute the votes are counted, investors do notice. Hinojosa campaigned on keeping data center approvals paused until the legislature writes new laws, so it is possible that Abbott’s ill-considered freeze could freeze right back up again in January.

Texas built its economic powerhouse by saying yes to people willing to put their own capital to work inside its borders. Natural gas is how you power a data center, and no state has more of that commodity than the Lone Star State. The SpaceX permit was always the easy call. It should not have taken an election to get it issued.

David Blackmon is an energy writer and consultant based in Texas. He spent 40 years in the oil and gas business, where he specialized in public policy and communications.

The views and opinions expressed in this commentary are those of the author and do not reflect the official position of the Daily Caller News Foundation.

All content created by the Daily Caller News Foundation, an independent and nonpartisan newswire service, is available without charge to any legitimate news publisher that can provide a large audience. All republished articles must include our logo, our reporter’s byline and their DCNF affiliation. For any questions about our guidelines or partnering with us, please contact [email protected].