Education

A Student Says Her High School Would Not Allow Her Pro-Life Club. The High School Denies It

Newborn_Baby | Circa October 2015 | Mindy Olson P mindyop via Wikimedia Commons

• Sophomore high school student Gabrielle Gabbard said her school refused to allow her to form a pro-life club.
• The Gulf Coast High School principal said the club is too “political” and “controversial,” Gabbard said.
• Representatives from Collier County Public Schools, however, said the “club was never refused.”

Gulf Coast High School student Gabrielle Gabbard said her high school refused to allow her pro-life club to form, but the Florida high school is denying the claim.

Gabbard, who is a sophomore and represented by the Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF), submitted the information required by Gulf Coast High School to form the pro-life club Sharks 4 Life on Aug. 8, according to a November letter ADF sent to the Collier County Public School Board. Sharks 4 Life would be affiliated with the nationwide pro-life organization Students for Life.

The letter stated that when Gabbard’s two faculty advisers met with Gulf Coast High School Assistant Principal Catherine Crawford-Brown on Aug. 30 to ask why the club had not yet been approved, Crawford-Brown told them the club was too “political” and “controversial,” and that a flyer Gabbard had submitted held unacceptable content. Crawford-Brown also suggested in this meeting that one of the faculty advisors might lose her job if she continued as a faculty advisor for the club, according to the letter, and the faculty advisor resigned that day.

But Gulf Coast High School “has been and is ready to open the club,” according to Chad Oliver, executive director of communication and community engagement for Collier County Public Schools.

“The Principal will be reaching out to students interested in forming the Sharks 4 Life Club on Monday and finding a sponsoring faculty member,” Oliver told the DCNF.

Jennifer L. Kupiec, a specialist in Communications & Community Engagement with Collier County Public Schools, also told the DCNF the high school never denied the club.

“The club was never refused or denied,” Kupiec told the DCNF. “Again, we are ready to open the club and will be in search of a faculty sponsor.”

Gabbard pushed back and said if the school had recognized the club, “we wouldn’t have taken the action we did.”

Gabbard reiterated that she has been working for several months to start a Sharks 4 Life club at Gulf Coast High School, but that the school told her the club was too political and controversial. Gulf Coast High School “has refused to approve it for over three months,” Gabbard told the DCNF in a statement.

“The fact of the matter is that Sharks 4 Life is not recognized by the school, and we are not able to reserve space, participate in school events, or otherwise act as a full club,” Gabbard said. “We hope the school will recognize Sharks 4 Life and change their policies to allow students to form clubs to support the issues students care about.”

Since ADF sent the letter to Gulf Country High School, the high school has agreed to move forward with recognizing the club, ADF senior counsel Tyson Langhofer told the DCNF. But Langhofer said this does not erase Gulf Country High School’s original refusal to recognize the club.

Gabbard’s legal representation also said Collier County’s failure to recognize Sharks 4 Life violates both the Equal Access Act and the First Amendment.

“Public school officials can’t refuse to recognize a student organization for being too ‘political’ or ‘controversial,’ especially when they have rightfully approved a whole host of other clubs formed around religious, political, and social interests,” ADF legal counsel Michael Ross said in a statement.

“The First Amendment doesn’t permit a public school to play favorites when approving student organizations,” he added. “Gulf Coast High School must recognize Sharks 4 Life, and Collier County Public Schools needs to update its policies so that this doesn’t happen again.”

Ross pointed out to the DCNF that Gulf Coast High School has over 78 different groups in its school, including the Fellowship of Christian Athletes, Animal Rights Club, Gay-Straight Alliance and Collier Students for Change, a group affiliated with the Florida Democratic Party.

“But they have said that our client can’t operate a pro-life group because it might be too political or too controversial,” Ross said.

ADF might pursue legal action if the school denies this request, he added.

“We will do whatever we need to to make sure that she can freely operate her pro-life student group on campus,” he said. “Right now we sent a demand letter to the school today saying that they need to immediately let the club operate or that we will be forced to pursue other legal remedies. So we will be willing to sue if it comes to that, but we’re hoping that the school will come around and do the right thing before we have to do that.”