Campus News

Supreme Court Declines To Review Racial Admissions Case At Elite High School

No featured image available

The Supreme Court on Tuesday declined to grant a writ of certiorari to review a case involving a racial admissions program at one of the most highly-ranked high schools in the country.

The Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology is a charter school located in Alexandria, Virginia, outside of Washington, D.C., and was ranked in 2021 and 2022 as the best public high school in the United States by the U.S. News and World Report, with a current national rank of 1 for college readiness and graduation rates. The school in 2020 was sued by a group of parents and students for implementing a new admissions policy that allegedly discriminated against Asian applicants, with the Court declining to alter a federal appellate court decision that affirmed the policy on Tuesday.

The decision of the court to deny certiorari, which requires the support of at least four justices, was opposed by Justices Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas. Alito wrote a dissent from the court’s denial of certiorari that criticized the majority for ignoring a case of affirmative action, which the Court previously ruled unconstitutional in Students for Fair Admissions, Inc. v. Harvard in 2023.

Coalition for TJ v. Fairfax County School Board, No. 23-170 (601 U.S.___, Feb. 20, 2024) (cert. denied) by Daily Caller News Foundation on Scribd

“The Court of Appeals’ decision in this case is based on a patently incorrect and dangerous understanding of what a plaintiff must show to prove intentional race discrimination,” wrote Altio in his dissent, which Thomas joined. “What the Fourth Circuit majority held, in essence, is that intentional racial discrimination is constitutional so long as it is not too severe. This reasoning is indefensible, and it cries out for correction.”

The case stems from the school’s decision in 2020 to change its admissions policy by abolishing a standardized examination and, instead, assess applicants based on a “holistic” evaluation that included an assessment of the applicant’s middle school and a points system for various factors, which included an applicant’s prior experiences. Before the policy was enacted, 73% of students at the school were of Asian ethnicities, a number that “fell substantially” thereafter, according to the petition for certiorari.

“The issue, in this case, is simple — did the Board’s overhaul violate the Equal Protection Clause?” wrote Coalition for TJ in its petition, referring to the U.S. Constitution’s 14th Amendment that prohibits states from denying to persons “equal protection of the law.” They argued that the policy was “applied and administered by a public authority with an evil eye and an unequal hand, so as practically to make unjust and illegal discriminations between persons in similar circumstances,” quoting previous Court precedents on the subject.

In 2020, the school’s principal, Ann Bonitatibus, publicly announced a plan to “enroll 180 black and 460 Hispanic students, filling nearly 22 classrooms,” according to the petition, which preceded changes to the admissions process. The announcement followed the death of George Floyd in Minneapolis, which provoked widespread protests across the country.

The petitioners did not immediately respond to a request for comment.